| Class Year | Swimmer | College/University |
| 2013 | Jeremy Bauchwitz | Johns Hopkins University |
| Carly DeLiberty | Towson University |
| Carrigan Eckels | Florida Atlantic University |
| Meghan Miller | Cleveland State |
| Shota Nakano | Indiana River State College |
| Ian Sherwood | Gettysburg College |
| Vinny Tafuto | University of Michigan |
| Ariana Waitkavicz | Johns Hopkins University |
| 2012 | Peter DeLuce | University of Delaware |
| Kegan Gerard (D) | American University |
| Alexis Grier | West Chester University |
| William Lee | Penn State University |
| Philip Mancuso | Penn State University |
| Carolyn McCarty | Army |
| Kyle Ruddle | Penn State University |
| Emma Santangelo | Layola University |
| Tanner Wilfong (D) | Miami University |
| 2011 | Ben Bauchwitz | MIT |
| Jacob Gordin | Franklin & Marshall |
| Ben Hagan | Naval Academy |
| Brittany Liedholm | George Washington |
| Katelyn Miller | Penn State University |
| Yurie Nakano | Indiana River State College |
| David Nolan | Stanford University |
| Kara VanBlargan | Gettysburg College |
| Jeffrey Young | Penn State University |
| 2010 | Joe Chubb | Lebanon Valley |
| Sean Grier | Penn State University |
| Fiona Mancuso | Ithica College |
| Samantha Rapp | Kenyon College |
| Caroline Vrana | Davidson College |
| Logan Wilfong | Susquehanna University |
| 2009 | Jordan Liedholm | George Washington |
| Katie Nolan | University of North Carolina |
| Nick Pawlush | Colgate University |
| 2008 | Evan Beatty | Juniata College |
| Jackie Gerhardt | St. Bonaventure |
| Amanda Jacobson | Albright University |
| Erica Rapp | William & Mary College |
| Abby Sheets | Bloomsburg University |
| Carly Wilfong | Lebanon Valley |
| 2007 | Kiersten Cooley | Northwestern University |
| Natazia Fistrovic | Fordham University |
| 2006 | Alex Barsanti | Clemson / Tennessee |
| Megan Cooney | Springfield College |
| Ed Felty | Penn State University |
| 2005 | Joe Bethards | Amherst College |
| Joe Cin (D) | William & Mary College |
| John Miller | Shippensburg Universty |
| Megan Patrick | Susquehanna University |
| Matt Watkins | Boston University |
| 2004 | Robert Felty | Penn State University |
| Jeff Fornadley | Susquehanna University |
| Ashley Jacobson | Seton Hall University |
| Gillian Kelly | Drexel University |
| Erin Kephart | Pepperdine University |
| Robin Kephart | Pepperdine University |
| Jesse Moore | William & Mary College |
| Erin Sarricks | James Madison University |
| Chris Weitkamp | University of Pennsylvania |
| 2003 | Katie Hoover | Kutztown University |
| Whitney Marshall | Penn State Erie |
| Jenna Walters | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2002 | Rebecca Chubb | Kutztown University |
| Caitlin Kelly | Mary Washington College |
| Chris Kurtz | Shippensburg Universty |
| 2001 | Tim Carvell | Shippensburg Universty |
| Erin Rosensteel | Lafayette College |
| 2000 | Ryan Gallagher | Susquehanna University |
| Iam Murray | Lehigh University |
| Robert Smith | James Madison University |
| 1997 | Steven Matthews | North Carolina State |
| Samantha Smith | James Madison University |
| 1996 | Rachel Chesney | Slippery Rock University |
| Teresa Hockman | East Carolina University |
| Charlotte Murray | Susquehanna University |
| 1995 | Shawnee Smith | James Madison University |
| 1993 | Jen Aber | Princeton University |
| 1981 | Ed Lanoue | Shippensburg Universty |
| 1979 | John Ricci (D) | West Chester University |
| 1971 | Tom Lutz | University of Tennessee |
